Loritwo.gif (24300 bytes)

Welcome
button.gif (899 bytes) CEJ's Mission
button.gif (899 bytes) Who We Are
button.gif (899 bytes) Accomplishments
button.gif (899 bytes) Publications
button.gif (899 bytes) How You Can Help
button.gif (899 bytes) Press Resources
Issues
button.gif (899 bytes) Tort Reform
button.gif (899 bytes) Insurance Regulation
button.gif (899 bytes) Credit Insurance
button.gif (899 bytes) Insurance Credit Scoring
button.gif (899 bytes) Redlining
button.gif (899 bytes) Health Insurance
button.gif (899 bytes) Telephone Availability
Bar.gif (1347 bytes)

1701A S. 2nd Street
Austin TX 78704
(512) 912 1327
(Fax) 912 1375

pdficon.gif (224 bytes) This report also available in pdf format

Memorandum

To: Public Utility Commission
From: D.J. Powers, Attorney for the Center For Economic Justice
Re: Denial Of Basic Telephone Service For Nonpayment Of Long Distance Charges

Question Presented

Under PURA 3.258(a), a telecommunications utility must provide basic local telephone service to all customers within its certified area, except as provided by statute. PURA 3.258(b)(1) permits discontinuation of service for nonpayment of "charges." The PUC promulgated rules that permit a telecommunications utility to deny service for nonpayment of charges for service other than basic local telephone service. Did the PUC have the authority to promulgate these rules?

Brief Answer

No. Administrative agencies may not promulgate rules which conflict with a statute. Under standard rules of statutory construction, the only "charges" for which nonpayment justifies disconnection are charges for basic local telephone service. In addition, the rules are defective because they authorize violations of the Texas Debt Collection Act.

arrownext.gif (1806 bytes)